Case Victory: Law Offices of Matthew J. Ruff Reverses Illegal DMV Refusal Suspension Following Lancaster Rollover Collision
The Incident: A Severe Crash and Hospital Transport
Late at night, emergency crews responded to a single-vehicle rollover crash on Northbound SR-14 south of Crown Valley Road. The driver was severely injured—suffering a potential arm fracture, broken ribs, and intense leg trauma—and was rushed to the Antelope Valley Hospital emergency room in Lancaster, CA, before California Highway Patrol (CHP) officers even arrived at the scene.
When a CHP officer later located the driver confined to an emergency room gurney, he initiated a brief questioning session. Finding the driver severely incapacitated, the officer asked if he would take a chemical blood test. Pain-ridden and hospitalized, the driver said "no". Officers proceeded to obtain a search warrant for a forced blood draw and automatically cited the driver for a Chemical Test Refusal under California Vehicle Code Section 13353.
Under California law, a chemical test refusal triggers an immediate 1-year mandatory license suspension with no option for a restricted driving permit.
The Legal Challenge: Missing Mandatory Admonition
Recognizing the officer's severe oversight, the driver retained Los Angeles DUI Defense Attorney Matthew J. Ruff to challenge the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) Driver Safety Branch in El Segundo.
Attorney Ruff filed a comprehensive legal Brief of Points and Authorities arguing that a driver cannot legally or factually "refuse" a chemical test unless law enforcement strictly fulfills the statutory prerequisite: fully reading the mandatory Chemical Test Admonition (DS 367) under California Vehicle Code § 23612.
Key Defense Points Raised by Attorney Matthew Ruff:
Unexecuted Admonition Form (DS 367): Attorney Ruff proved through CHP’s own official documentation that the legal advisement section was left completely blank. The fields for time, applicable choices, and driver response details were omitted entirely.
Merely Asking "No" Is Not Enough: The officer's own arrest report confirmed he simply asked the injured driver if he would submit to a blood test, failing to inform him that declining would trigger an automatic one-year license suspension.
Impact of Severe Physical Trauma: Because the driver was immobilized on a gurney and in medical distress, officers were required to strictly adhere to statutory advisements to ensure a driver's response isn't a byproduct of trauma, confusion, or severe pain.
The Verdict: DMV License Suspension Fully Set Aside
Following review of Attorney Ruff’s brief and the evidence, the Department of Motor Vehicles Legal Affairs Division officially issued an Order of Set Aside on August 25, 2026. The DMV ruled that law enforcement failed to satisfy the required elements under CVC § 13353.
The Result: The 1-year refusal suspension was completely erased, and full driving privileges were restored.